David Gerard wrote:
On 19/10/2007, Will Beback will.beback.1@gmail.com wrote:
I again dispute that removing poor sources harms NPOV.
Do you believe that Making Light suddenly became a poorer source, such that every link immediately had to be removed from the article base, the day Kathryn Cramer started flinging monkey dung at you personally?
[ ] Yes [ ] No
Did your edit summaries reflect this?
[ ] Yes [ ] No
- d.
I believe that when an editor on Wikipedia gets into a dispute and uses their blog as a weapon in that dispute, then that the blog is no longer a suitable source for Wikipedia. We have plenty of good ways to resolve personal or content disputes between editors. We should do everything we can to discourage disgruntled editors from using outside websites to affect Wikipedia content and POV.
This thread is concerned with future proposals, not past errors. If you want to discuss the past we can do so in a private exchange.
Will