On Sat, 10 Nov 2007 09:58:10 -0500, "Alec Conroy" alecmconroy@gmail.com wrote:
I don't care a hoot about Bagley, Barber, Awbry, Adolph Hitler, or Emmanuel Goldstein. How to treat banned users is NOT in contention.
Something tells me you just violated Godwin's Law.
What I've been discussing is your treatment of DanT, PM, GTBacchus, and anyone else who you think is even remotely affiliateded with WR, ED, or other BADSITES. Unfortunately, we seem to be talking past each other.
I can't recall the last interaction I had with GTBacchus, and my interaction with PM was limited to trying to stop one example of an increasing tendency to abuse multiple accounts; when three arbitrators chip in to say that this use of alternate accounts was inappropriate, I'd say it was inappropriate.
I am, however, very concerned at the pernicious influence of that particular site on Wikipedia editors, as evidenced in the Alkivar arbitration.
Guy (JzG)