On 10/18/05, Tony Sidaway f.crdfa@gmail.com wrote:
Actually I stopped by the talk page of that article this morning, and Snowspinner has done a very good job of listing and critiquing every one of nearly 70 references, most of which seem to have been blogs, agitprop websites, and Michael Moore. _____________________________________
Yeah, after I sorted through all the articles I found his comments too (on one of them - I opened the while series and started looking at talk page after talk page with no comments). In addition, if yoiu look at the one talk page where this came up, the citations only came up after Ryan took him to task for the tag, and it doesn't look like this conversation has gone any further, so with regards to his comments above "A nice sentiment, but in this case naive - I slapped dispute tags on them, and I'm already being threatened with reverts", my comments are still valid - if someone slaps disputed tags on an article without explaining the dispute, taking issue with them is the correct thing to do.
Ian