From: "Tony Sidaway" minorityreport@bluebottle.com JAY JG said:
and in particular, when I see someone voting "keep, good stub" etc. on a completely useless stub.
Oh, you mean someone who disagrees with you?
No, Tony, and I find your strawman arguments tiresome; that's two in one discussion. Do you think you could possibly avoid them in the future, or do find their rhetorical power too irresistable?
So you've got people who have been at it for some time who aren't mindless robotic posters, and you've got people who only responded robotically to robotic deletion listings.
This doesn't quite square the circle.
Your apologetics are interesting examples of rationalization, but the bottom line remains that a group of school inclusionists, organized via a school inclusionist page, were robotically voting identical "keep" votes on large sets of school deletions.
Jay.