On 24/09/06, Stephen Streater sbstreater@mac.com wrote:
On 24 Sep 2006, at 14:10, David Gerard wrote:
Have you reviewed the history of other notability guidelines? Why did they fail? If you can't answer that, you need to be able to.
I thought the biggest problem was that they didn't implement policy.
I think the biggest problem was that they just didn't convince people other than the proponents.
(You can't claim that people are required to dive into a potential wiki-shitfight over what seems a fundamentally bad idea before they can object to a bad idea that affects them.)
If you can come up with a notability policy that follows obviously and elegantly from the one-sentence summaries of NPOV, NOR and V [*], then it'll definitely fly. If not, it's unlikely to.
- d.
[*] I specify the one-sentence summaries because you just know that if I didn't then some creative soul would carefully choose suitable supporting sentences out of the long written pages.