On 6/11/07, MacGyverMagic/Mgm macgyvermagic@gmail.com wrote:
On 6/11/07, Jeff Raymond jeff.raymond@internationalhouseofbacon.com wrote:
On Mon, June 11, 2007 7:39 am, Anthony wrote:
"Bill Gill
Elementary School is an elementary school in Tampa, Florida"?
Schools are contentious issues. If that sentence is all there is in the article, you can speedy it under lack of content before even thinking about notability.
Except that "lack of content" isn't a CSD criterion. "no meaningful content" is, but this has meaningful content. "Very short articles providing little or no context" is, but that criterion is very explicit that "context" is not the same thing as "content".
In other cases, you can run it past the Schools WikiProject to see if they can dig up something that makes the school worth writing about. (I find [[WP:BEEFSTEW]] useful in this regard).
"Westwood Football Club, formed in 2004 by a group of Bangladeshi
football fans on the streets of Oldham have been recognised for their work with youths, preventing and combating anti-social behaviour"?
Are they covered in the national media? Are they covered by international media. Have they been on local tv. How have they been recognized (any awards). If this is to be deleted, it's an AFD issue, not speedy.
This was deleted. Speedily. As an A7.
"Suzanne Westwood was a soldier who was killed in Iraq"?
CSD lack of content/context unless anything else can be said. A lot soldiers die (too many) but an article on a soldier killed in Iraq stands or falls with teh amount of meat it has.
Again I disagree that there is a lack of context. A full name and the fact that they were killed in Iraq is enough to make it clear exactly who is being talked about. The question of whether or not it falls under A7 is completely dependent on whether or not you think a soldier who died in Iraq is important enough for an encyclopedia. IOW, CSD A7 means whatever the deleting admin wants it to mean.