On 5/23/07, Ken Arromdee arromdee@rahul.net wrote:
On Tue, 22 May 2007, John Lee wrote:
The problem, as I and others have raised, is that defining a spoiler is extremely difficult to do without violating [[WP:NOR]]. How do we know
what
a spoiler is?
I'll say it again: meta decisions--about article content--are not subject to NOR.
I've already explained before why this is not your garden variety editorial judgment. As I said, how the heck do we draw a line at what constitutes an inappropriate surprise to readers and what does not? We *need* some point of reference for this, or it all breaks down.
Johnleemk