On 11/13/06, Phil Sandifer Snowspinner@gmail.com wrote:
In my experience, PRODs will take place about 80% of the time, but of that 80% about 25% will later be contested. So far I've seen exactly one article that really should have died survive a PROD and an AfD, and one more get PRODded, undeleted, and then survive AfD.
80% of completed prods later contested? This sounds *very* high to me and is completely inconsistent with the undo rate for discussionless deletion. What data did you base this conclusion on?
In general I'd agree with the notion that greater scrutiny tends to cause more and more surprising outcomes... and I'm not quite sure what to make of that.