Tucci wrote
I'm not sure I understand this distinction, [...]
The [[scholarship]] article is not bad. I like the definition elsewhere at [[rigour]] - wrote it myself - as 'quality control of information'; but I can see that others might find it narrow. Anyway, on a narrow definition ,I can't see the problem with Wikipedians checking facts and being critical about source material. Five minutes of googling shows that you need all that.
Charles