Steve Bennett wrote:
On 6/6/06, Scott Stevenson wikinetscott@gmail.com wrote:
Resid, [[WP:OURS]] was speedy deleted because it fell under [[WP:CSD#General_criteria]] (general criteria 5), which states as a valid reason for speedy deletion : "Pages created by banned usershttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:List_of_banned_userswhile they were banned http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Banning_policy." You are a
This is a much better reason for deleting something than concerns about copyright.
It would be a better reason, if it wouldn't be just plain wrong. Neither [[User:Rgulerdem/Wikiethics]] nor [[User:Raphael1/Wikiethics]] has been created by banned users while they were banned.
Netscott claims, that there had been some edits on [[User:Rgulerdem/Wikiethics]] from an IP-address he alleges to be Rgulerdems. IIRC I have made a copy of that page to [[User:Raphael1/Wikiethics]] before Rgulerdem even had been banned.
Anyway, even if Netscotts allegations are true, neither [[User:Rgulerdem/Wikiethics]] nor [[User:Raphael1/Wikiethics]] has been created by banned users while they were banned.
best regards