Angela wrote:
I strongly feel these should only appear on talk pages, but I gave up arguing that a while ago because people insist on having them on articles, supposedly because they feel readers need to be warned the article is not good enough.
I think they ought to go on articles, but with a higher threshold of "suckiness". An article that needs a little work shouldn't go on cleanup, by my understanding of its intent. An article that was wholesale copy/pasted from a PD source with no wikification or rewriting should get the tag, as should an article that appears to be completely incoherent.
-Mark