On 2006-07-23, Steve Bennett stevagewp@gmail.com wrote:
I'm stunned. I've started [[Wikipedia:List of POV forks]] to deal with this. This is a really serious violation of NPOV, far more so than quibbles over whether individual sentences of individual articles contain the correct tone or not.
I think I remember participating in a discussion about one such article. Those who were for the existence of the article made the point that "criticism" doesn't necessarily imply that the commentary is negative (although it is often used in this way). Therefore a "Criticism of..." article should cover views both pro- and contra-.