On 6/24/06, fireislandparadise fireislandparadise@gmail.com wrote:
My problem is that not requiring a warning encourages gaming by making it easier for a more savvy edit warrior to take advantage of another editor and play "gotcha". This is particularly the case as most editors aren't aware of the new "unrelated reverts" interpretation. If someone is savvy enough to complain on ANI/3RR they should be capable of giving someone a warning first, especially if they are a participant in the edit war.
Is "gotcha" a big problem? Let's see: * You can only do it once, ever, to a single editor * You can only do it when the person has reverted 3 times in a single day, something we wish to discourage * The punishment is only banning for 24 hours.
Sure, it could happen. But it's probably not worth worrying about.
Steve