On 9/15/05, Tony Sidaway f.crdfa@gmail.com wrote:
There is a serious problem with undeletion policy, rendering it incompatible with other Wikipedia policies.
Firstly undeletion requires a majority (50%). Wikipedia is not a democracy, we should do changes by consensus.
Secondly the undeletion policy is inconsistent with deletion policy. The main principle of deletion policy is "if in doubt, don't delete". It follows that a consensus should be required to keep a page deleted.
Hmm, I never knew it was that bad. It *definitely* has to change.