Looking at the things tagged by the reviewer (http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special_relativity&diff=781074...), almost every single one would warrant a "This is accepted by virtually all scholars" note. Where does it end? Should every factual statement have such a tag? Surely students can figure out what a References section is and just pick up one of those books.
I'm am very pro-citation when it helps us build a better encyclopedia, but I'm anti-"let's footnote everything even though it appears in any textbook on the subject and is totally uncontroversial, just to satisfy a process decision".
On 9/29/06, Nathaniel Sheetz preparing@psu.edu wrote:
On 9/29/06, Mak makwik@gmail.com wrote:
I've just attempted to explain why having inline citations can be misleading. If a fact is widely agreed on, and you ascribe it to a single source or author, it makes it seem as though that person is the sole proponent of that idea, when in fact pretty much everyone in the field is in agreement.
You don't have to list just one person in the citation. What's wrong with including <ref>This is accepted by virtually all scholars, including Einstein in ''Book X'', Murphy in ''Article Y'', and Jones in "Article Z''.</ref> Then put the bibliographic information in the references section, as usual.
Also, in response to the original post, citations do more than just serve as a way to verify the facts of an article. They also show where the material came from, which is helpful for anyone doing research on a topic (high school, college, etc.) who can't directly cite Wikipedia (not many teachers allow that). Our articles need to be written so that they can be used by as many people as possible, and I think that one way to do that is to religiously cite sources.
Nathaniel ([[User:Spangineer]], a real nuisance to many on FAC when it comes to citations) _______________________________________________ WikiEN-l mailing list WikiEN-l@Wikipedia.org To unsubscribe from this mailing list, visit: http://mail.wikipedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikien-l