Rebecca wrote:
Absolutely no one here appears to be suggesting that stubs are bad. If we had any deletionists at all who were as hardline as Anthony, Mark Richards or Mr. Knight, then that's probably what they would argue.
Hardline? As in hardline inclusionist? Excuse me one moment... *off in the distance you hear a great deal of laughter*
I'm sorry... hehehe... I'm back now... hehehehehehe...
Perhaps you'd care to pay a little more attention to my arguments? (Not to mention my past history? 1-1.5 years ago on this very list I opposed measures that made it more troublesome to get articles deleted.)
I joined Ray Saintonge in rejecting some notions of what criteria should be used in deleting articles, argued with John Lee over a few of those notions (later finding out it was partially a misunderstanding due to the insane number of ways people are using "notability" in this discussion), and commented on one specific case John brought up which I felt was a clear-cut abuse of VFD.
I don't think I've ever even voted on VFD one way or another. A quick glance at a few current entries reveal three I think should probably be deleted, one I think shouldn't be, and one I'm not too sure of.
This is "hardline"? Just what would your definition of moderate be?