Regardless of some uncertainty among us regarding the specifics we made a finding of fact that you had abused your position as an administrator. While the incident was relatively minor your subsequent activities show you continue to maintain that you believe you did little wrong and that nothing ought to be done. It is not at all hard to decide on a remedy under these circumstances. No amount of wikilawyering, however sophisticated, is going to work.
Fred
On Nov 3, 2005, at 8:12 PM, steve v wrote:
- Jayjg: "I think the wording needs to be modified to
something like "gain undue advantage with respect to a dispute etc...."
- James: "I absolutely, vehemently disagree. The use
of the rollback button must always be used only for reverting pure vandalism..."
- Fred: "I don't think this is about using rollback
for a revert. It is about unblocking yourself after a 3RR block then editing a protected page...."
The rub, for those who missed it: There should be some agreement on what the actual offense is before deciding on a penalty.