I don't recommend that we "give in". I do recommend that we continue to dialog about possibilities which would be satisfactory to all sides.
To do that, you need to define what the sides are. We're never going to completely satisfy everybody. The most unreasonable claims can obviously be rejected outright (for example, someone mentioned a demand that only Muslims be allowed to edit Islam-related articles). We need to decide how unreasonable is unreasonable enough to dismiss without consideration.