Sam Korn wrote:
Examples would be a perfect place to start. There appear to be two main criticisms of AfD:
- Unreliability. This appears to be your point.
- Bad and unhealthy atmosphere.
There was some discussion earlier about Comixpedia having forked from Wikipedia as a result of articles on web comics being deleted on account of being "non-notable" or somesuch. I don't know anything about that myself, but if it's the case then that would seem like a good example to dig evidence out of. Anyone have any handy?