james duffy wrote:
Whatever about the text's problems, the central one was that it was on the wrong page. That page was exclusively to do with a political science definition of 'communist state',
But the title of the page is just [[Communist state]], and so your declaration that the page should be limited to just a techincal definition is possibly premature.
Yet he consistently ignored every contributor and reverted to his poorly written irrelevant material, burying major changes as minor edits, on occasion reverting minute by minute.
I don't condone any of that, and yet, I can't help but point out that it "takes two to tango" -- every time he was reverting minute-by-minute, so was someone else.
His text was everything you say it is -- POV, and in the wrong location (at best), and partly false (perhaps). And yet, I think that it's worthwhile for everyone (especially Fred, but others, too) to take stock of how this might have been handled more amicably.
--Jimbo