On 5/11/06, jf_wikipedia@mac.com jf_wikipedia@mac.com wrote:
Would you be kind enough to suggest moving [[:Category:Criminals]] to [[:Category:People convicted of crime]]?
-- Jossi
And likewise renaming all the subcategories, and sub-sub-categories?
What about people who were never convicted? Was Lee Harvey Oswald ever posthumously convicted of murder? If not, do we have to take him out of [[Category:Murderers]], now renamed to [[Category:People convicted of murder]]? Or maybe it should be renamed [[Category:People who either were convicted of murder or who otherwise are believed by the vast majority of people to have committed murder]]?
Sometimes I wonder whether categories were ever a good idea to begin with. They were certainly implemented horribly.
Anthony