If there is to be a new deletion policy workup, there ought be a focused community decision -- a front page blurb to the meta page, and some kind of temporary sanction for the Wikipedia:Cleanup page -- which is under attack on VFD simply because it was sort of "imposed on the community."
Again, wiki is limited in terms of what you can do on a single page, this is why its important to have a process by which pages dont go directly to the Dump/dump not to be fought over but instead go Cleanup or PNA. In some ways Cleanup might be PNA with a different name, but I think that PNA would better be used for longer term items, while cleanup (with extremely limited comment) can be used to draw some attention to something that should be on a track--either to the trash, for a redirect, etc. I can see how some see it as a bypassing of VFD -- but given that pages can be restored if they are deleted too quickly (ie nonsense pages), but thats not what its for-- again its to deal with articles in a general sense leaving VFD for those where there is actually some debate.
~S~
__________________________________ Do you Yahoo!? The New Yahoo! Shopping - with improved product search http://shopping.yahoo.com