<quote name="Steven Walling" date="2014-03-10" time="17:47:56
+0000">
On Mon, Mar 10, 2014 at 5:22 PM, Greg Grossmeier
<greg(a)wikimedia.org> wrote:
There's a lot of changes in Typography
Refresh. One of the many is the
font css rule. The majority are changes that do not implicate the
Freeness of anything. The font does. The font change (originally) only
had a benefit to Mac OS users (right?).
No.
Awesome.
Now the font change (after
Ryan's amazing work, which should have been done at the beginning) it
includes a benefit for people who will now get Liberation instead of
DejaVu (right?).
So, if my two (right?)'s above are correct, that makes me feel like the
design team only cared about OSX/iOS users before, and only after a LOT
of complaining on the various lists and bugs and such did they put in
the effort to see IF they could improve the experience for non-Apple
products.
Again no. We tested on Linux systems starting months ago, with the
developers who have been working on this. Several of our iterations were
focused on trying out free/open fonts to put first, and getting feedback
about that.
Cool. That's great.
I find it also
corroborated by the request from a Design team
member for access to a Windows computer to do testing on *last week*.
Vibha asked for a Windows machine because she does not normally do testing
on Windows herself, as a designer. The developers and product managers do
this testing, and we all sit down (or share screenshots remotely) to take a
look. Kaldari, who was working with Vibha at the time, doesn't trust
virtual machine-based testing of fonts. That's why they asked for a Windows
machine.
Makes sense, sorry for misinterpreting it.
That may or may not be an accurate way to
describe the situation,
historically, but that's how the narrative can easily be interpreted and
it is what I'm feeling from these discussions where I'm being told my
preference for not promoting proprietary stuff is "irrational."
This is not an accurate or fair representation. This kind of attitude ("all
designers care about is OSX") is the kind of pernicious meme that drives
good designers away from working on free software projects. It's akin to
saying "women don't participate in $free_project because they aren't
interested in working on free software".
Sorry, I didn't mean to say that all designers only care about OSX, but
based on my (apparently incorrect) understanding above that's what this
specific change seemed like to me.
So, thanks for the clarifications of my (mis)understanding.
May I ask the design team to update
https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Typography_refresh with the current state
of affairs/plans and what the changes mean for various platforms (as
best as we can assume, I know how dumb the general font-rending
non-deterministicness is)?
Thanks,
Greg
--
| Greg Grossmeier GPG: B2FA 27B1 F7EB D327 6B8E |
| identi.ca: @greg A18D 1138 8E47 FAC8 1C7D |