On 2/10/07, Andre Engels <andreengels(a)gmail.com> wrote:
I don't see what's odd about that. It's a
work, copyrighted by you, under
CC-BY-SA, and based on a public domain work. It's no different than the same
situation would have been if the music had been not 51 but 300 years old.
And little different than the same situation where you had not put it under
CC-BY-SA.
But CC-By-SA is claiming the film is a derivative of the sound
recording despite film and sound being seperate under uk law. So even
though I have made no changes to the music CC-By-SA is trying to claim
it is under copyright again because is it is part of a film.
Another way to look at this is that CC thinks that the soundtrack of a
51 year old film in the UK is not PD.
--
geni