Friends, Family, USU IT Faculty, Grad Students & Alumni,
It's only in its infancy (pre-conception, you might even say), but I wanted to let you all know about a project that I've started to think about, under the guidance/tutelage of Dr. Wiley here at USU.
It is currently called the "Utah OpenTextbooks Project" (codenamed "Project Dyson" by Dr. Wiley)--and I am considering doing my dissertation around it. The basic gist is as follows:
The state of Utah, and other states like it, spend over $20M annually on K-12 textbooks. With that kind of money, and with shrinking educational budgets, a few questions are worth asking:
* Are these textbooks worth the $$$? Also, does a brand new U.S. History or Algebra 1 textbook need to be repurchased every few years (at full cost) for whatever few changes may be made? * Do we want a handful of states (New York, California, Florida, Texas) driving the content of textbooks in all the other states (which is basically what happens today, as I¹m told)? * Could better, more innovate textbooks be developed in a community/open/wiki style (see http://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Main_Page and www.opensourcetext.org for starters), where the COMMUNITY would retain ownership of the contentor better yet, share w/ other states/countries? * Once a textbook has been written by a community, could digital learning objects be built around the text/course and provided as supplements to the textbookhelping teachers teach better, and learners learn better (think free multimedia clips for lectures, test banks and innovate lesson plans for teachers, or cool multimedia games/self-direct modules for student homework, etc.) * Finally, if we can create ³local² (statewide) online communities where teachers, students, and subject matter experts congregate to create textbooks, share lesson plans, and basically socialize in the context of an academic course...can we harness the power of the internet in more positive ways...to far more productive ends (think ³replace MTV or Xbox with Utah Math Rocks Internet Plaza¹²?
I have attached a very, very rough "Vision Document" that outlines what we have brainstormed, and some early, high-level steps on how we might go about achieving our vision. If you are not comfortable opening attachments from an email (can¹t imagine why you would be :) ), feel free to download the document from: http://f4.grp.yahoofs.com/v1/oL1RQdNHDrnawcLP1c-av2v_Y1LRpZ_PL_4Paj7XwHCX0b_ 09Ppay-jJ0791jStsb2IgwQl1VSP0Rf6L3jpxxg/Utah%20OpenTextbooks%20Project.doc
We need lots of input/ideas/feedback, so if any of you are interested in participating in/supporting this project in any way (even as a silent observer), please feel free to reply w/ feedback, or even join our community at: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/utahopentextbooks
Also, if you know anyone interested in Utah Education, or Open Textbooks, please feel free to forward this message to them.
I look forward to collaborating w/ those of you who are interested. It will be a long journey to be sure, but hopefully a worthwhile one.
John Dehlin Director of Outreach OSLO Research Group http://oslo.usu.edu/people/jdehlin Utah State University
A few of you have said that you were unable to download/read the attachment, so I am including the ³Vision Document² below:
-------------------------
Utah OpenTextbooks Project
Overview: The Utah OpenTextbooks Project will cultivate a grassroots community of K-12 teachers, students, university professors, educational administrators, and concerned citizens within the state of Utah, with the intent of creating open, free textbooks, along with supplemental digital learning materials, for educational use.
The Vision: Within 5-10 years (2010-2015), we see the following as within reach: * Utah Saving Millions of $$$ in Textbook Costs: The state of Utah could save literally millions of dollars a year in textbook costs by replacing expensive textbooks with free, open textbooks (currently the annual K-12 budget for textbooks in Utah alone is $20M) * UTAH State Standards: Utah OpenTextbooks will be directly \aligned with both Utah state curriculum and local priorities/preferencesand will not be oriented towards the curriculum, preferences, or social norms of other states (e.g. New York, California, Florida, and Texas). * Helping Teachers Teach Better, with Less Time Commitment: A major goal of ours is to SIMPLIFY teacher¹s lives, by providing them with time-saving course materials, while still helping them improve their overall instruction. A few ideas include:
- Teacher subject matter knowledge and passion will increase through
participation in the ³online teacher communities², as well as through increased direct involvement in both content development and selection.
- By allowing teachers to share with each other quality digital supplemental
course material designed around a specific textbook (multimedia clips for lectures, digital self-paced learning objects for student homework, test banks, classroom exercises, etc), we hope to dramatically simplify teacher¹s overall jobs, while still helping them improve their level of instruction
* Helping Students Learn More via Social Networks and Digital ContentToday, our competition for student time includes alternatives like Xbox, MTV, Internet Forums, etc. By intermingling student learning with social groups via a digital medium, we hope to create a special sauce¹ that will lead to increased student interest, involvement and enjoyment in learning like never before (making it ³cool² to learn, from a social perspective, and allowing students to develop/foster social relationships within a learning context).
- Subject-specific online learning communities for students will be
cultivated, such that students can ³socialize² with other students from around the state in a learning environment (killing 3 birds with one stone by facilitating learning, socialization, and fun simultaneously).
- Classroom lectures/activities become better for students, by providing
professors with better materials for lectures and activities (see above)
- By providing students with well-designed digital learning objects (digital
text, self-paced learning modules, multimedia clips, etc), students can learn at their own pace, in a digital environment that is more familiar, and potentially more compelling.
- As the communities begin to mature, city-wide and even state-wide
competitions could be held (think of online or state-wide history or math tournaments), where students gain notoriety/respect/success (ratings? Rankings?) for excelling within specific subject areas.
How We Will Do This: 1. Online Community: For starters, we will create an online community of educators, and actively recruit participants. Currently, this forum is located at: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/utahopentextbooks. We will seek to recruit members from: a) contacts in Logan/Cache Valley and at Utah State University, b) the Utah Educators Association, c) the Utah Educators Network, and d) any other area/forum where Utah educators congregate. 2. The ³Kernel² (our 1st Textbook)To borrow on a software-related metaphor, the ³kernel² of our efforts will be the creation of a single community and textbook (we are thinking U.S. History to start with). We will try to find an author of an existing text (or other opentextbook initiative) who is willing to ³donate² their textbook to our cause as a foundation. If we can¹t find this, we will seek grant money to pay 4 or 5 university professors and/or teachers $20K each ($100K total) to help design the 1st textbook over a year¹s time. This book will be developed:
- DIRECTLY based on Utah State curriculum requirements
- With EXTENSIVE input from real, live, active teachers in the given field
- With a ³Wiki² approach (see www.wikipedia.org http://www.wikipedia.org ).
While we are intent on approaching the design of this text w/ a spirit of openness and community, we will optimize around creating a quality text in a reasonable amount of time (1 year?)and will sacrifice openness (in terms of authoring, not input) to ensure a quality/timely release. 2 potential models for development include:
- 5 paid authorsthousands of volunteer reviewers
- Thousands of volunteer authors5 paid editors/reviewers (gate-keepers)
- Digital Content: We will seek to obtain digital content for the textbook
from any/all available sources, including the Library of Congress, National Archives, National Science Foundation, other learning object repositories, etc.
3. Printing and Evangelizing the Textbook: While this textbook will be fully digital/online, it will also be available via print. We will locate a printer who is able to print a quality version of this text (hard copy?) for under $5/copy. Once the 1st textbook is completed, it will be evangelized to charter schools, school districts, and even the state of Utah for pilot usage. 4. Supplemental Digital Content Libraries: Once the text is completed (or perhaps in parallel), the community will be invited to submit digital ³learning objects² to supplement the text. Possible items for submission will include:
- Lesson plans, including supplemental digital multimedia
- Group exercises
- Student homework /assignments
- Test questions
- Other supplemental instruction or learning materials
What will differentiate our content repository from the plethora of other ³failed² content repositories is: 1. It will be directly associated with a specific course/textbook, instead of generic subjectsthus teachers will have much more of a direct interest in participating. 2. By fostering usage within a unified state/systemwe will be able to create a critical mass of community members, with enough in common, and with enough mutual familiarity, to add real value to the individual members. The content will be created and evangelized via a local community of teachers (³viral marketing²) 3. The content (text and digital learning objects) will be rated by teachers AND learners, such that a ³virtual feedback loop² will be digitally enabled (leading to dramatic content improvement). As far as learning objects go, only a few of the VERY BEST content objects will be recommended for each section of instruction. In other wordsSIMPLIFIED CHOICES, SUPER HIGH QUALITY.
And of course, this initiative will likely solve world peace, world hunger, and general moral decaybut I wanted to keep predictions relatively conservative at this point. J
John,
I just got the emails that you included to the Wikibooks mailing list. As the founder of Wikibooks, I would be excited and honored if you chose to include the site in your plans.
Karl
--- John Dehlin john.dehlin@usu.edu wrote:
__________________________________________________ Do You Yahoo!? Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around http://mail.yahoo.com
Karl,
I am honored to hear from you, and very, every interested in the idea of collaborating w/ Wikipedia.
Here's my main reaction/thoughts so far.....
When we decided to try the open textbook thing, one of the first places we looked was Wikipedia. However, as I've poked around the site for mature, usable textbooks (like state-adoption quality), I haven't been able to find any. Also, it seems overall like the inertia behind wiki-textbooks has sort of stalled as of late (as evidenced by how long it took my posts to get through, and how little traffic there is on this alias in general).
I don't mean to be a pessimist at all....and please know that these things I describe are in no way non-starters for me/us....but I would love to hear from some of you if my impressions are correct, and if they are, what explanations you may have as to the slowdown in momentum (this would be most helpful of all).
Top of mind for me/us is having this project succeed--we feel like the world needs high quality, low cost textbooks. Again, I can think of a million good reasons to go w/ Wikipedia.....I just want to understand a little more, and ultimately we will want to go with whatever infrastructure/community will lead us to this end. We'd love it to be Wikipedia.
John Dehlin Oslo Outreach Director http://oslo.usu.edu
On 11/24/04 2:46 PM, "Karl Wick" karlwick@yahoo.com wrote:
John,
I just got the emails that you included to the Wikibooks mailing list. As the founder of Wikibooks, I would be excited and honored if you chose to include the site in your plans.
Karl
--- John Dehlin john.dehlin@usu.edu wrote:
Do You Yahoo!? Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around http://mail.yahoo.com _______________________________________________ Textbook-l mailing list Textbook-l@wikimedia.org http://mail.wikipedia.org/mailman/listinfo/textbook-l
FYI. We would love to collaborate w/ wikimedia.org.
John Dehlin
------ Forwarded Message
Subject: Utah OpenTexbooks Project (Project Dyson)
Friends, Family, USU IT Faculty, Grad Students & Alumni,
It's only in its infancy (pre-conception, you might even say), but I wanted to let you all know about a project that I've started to think about, under the guidance/tutelage of Dr. Wiley here at USU.
It is currently called the "Utah OpenTextbooks Project" (codenamed "Project Dyson" by Dr. Wiley)--and I am considering doing my dissertation around it. The basic gist is as follows:
The state of Utah, and other states like it, spend over $20M annually on K-12 textbooks. With that kind of money, and with shrinking educational budgets, a few questions are worth asking:
* Are these textbooks worth the $$$? Also, does a brand new U.S. History or Algebra 1 textbook need to be repurchased every few years (at full cost) for whatever few changes may be made? * Do we want a handful of states (New York, California, Florida, Texas) driving the content of textbooks in all the other states (which is basically what happens today, as I¹m told)? * Could better, more innovate textbooks be developed in a community/open/wiki style (see http://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Main_Page and www.opensourcetext.org for starters), where the COMMUNITY would retain ownership of the contentor better yet, share w/ other states/countries? * Once a textbook has been written by a community, could digital learning objects be built around the text/course and provided as supplements to the textbookhelping teachers teach better, and learners learn better (think free multimedia clips for lectures, test banks and innovate lesson plans for teachers, or cool multimedia games/self-direct modules for student homework, etc.) * Finally, if we can create ³local² (statewide) online communities where teachers, students, and subject matter experts congregate to create textbooks, share lesson plans, and basically socialize in the context of an academic course...can we harness the power of the internet in more positive ways...to far more productive ends (think ³replace MTV or Xbox with Utah Math Rocks Internet Plaza¹²?
I have attached a very, very rough "Vision Document" that outlines what we have brainstormed, and some early, high-level steps on how we might go about achieving our vision. If you are not comfortable opening attachments from an email (can¹t imagine why you would be :) ), feel free to download the document from: http://f4.grp.yahoofs.com/v1/oL1RQdNHDrnawcLP1c-av2v_Y1LRpZ_PL_4Paj7XwHCX0b_ 09Ppay-jJ0791jStsb2IgwQl1VSP0Rf6L3jpxxg/Utah%20OpenTextbooks%20Project.doc
We need lots of input/ideas/feedback, so if any of you are interested in participating in/supporting this project in any way (even as a silent observer), please feel free to reply w/ feedback, or even join our community at: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/utahopentextbooks
Also, if you know anyone interested in Utah Education, or Open Textbooks, please feel free to forward this message to them.
I look forward to collaborating w/ those of you who are interested. It will be a long journey to be sure, but hopefully a worthwhile one.
John Dehlin Director of Outreach OSLO Research Group http://oslo.usu.edu/people/jdehlin Utah State University
------ End of Forwarded Message
textbook-l@lists.wikimedia.org