--- Karl Wick karlwick@yahoo.com wrote:
If the main reason to have a required sign-in for page editing is to fight against vandals, is there another solution that would have the same benefits without the drawbacks ?
etc...
I find it hard to believe that on such a new topic, with so much to discuss, so much time is spent talking on vandalism issues. Aren't there more to discuss than vandalism ? Vandalism will occur. And vandalism can be treated just the way it is on Wikipedia. If the project is so different that it requires other ways to manage vandalism, just wait the moment it will happen. Right now, why don't you assume you will not be able to use similar ways that the ones used on other wiki projects ?
__________________________________ Do you Yahoo!? SBC Yahoo! DSL - Now only $29.95 per month! http://sbc.yahoo.com