On 7 February 2010 08:45, Andrew Garrett agarrett@wikimedia.org wrote:

Not at all, it's entirely reasonable to discuss the problems associated with the current categorisation system, and what methods we'd like to use to improve it.

The current categorization system is per-wiki-specific. It's done differently in different places. So it's not clear that you won't require 750 different discussions.

To get back to the topic of category intersections on Commons:

Could the developers please outline, point by point, the precise hoops we need to jump through to get category intersections on Commons? New hoops seem to have been introduced during the currently discussion.

Please make an unambiguous list of the hoops Commons will be required to jump through before this feature can happen, so it's actually clear to all and we're all working from the same page, rather than trying to guess what shrubbery you'll be demanding next.

Thanks!

- d.