2012/3/1 Pratik Lahoti pr4tiklahoti@gmail.com:
Hisham - 51 edits Nitika.t - 46 edits Noopur28 - 29 edits Karthikndr - 11 edits
Hi Prateek,
Thank you for your efforts at coordinating the INCOTM. Here's a suggestion: an effective way for assessment of contributions should be done by examining the quality of the contributions rather than the number of edits (re: "top editors"). For instance, even though Karthik Nadar has 11 edits, he has brought in valuable references for the article, and in contrast, Hisham's contribution with 51 edits has been minor gnoming and copy-editing of the page. An analysis to that effect would be more helpful to the users of this list along with examples of great edits. Thanks.
Best, anirudh
Wikimedia-in-en mailing list Wikimedia-in-en@lists.wikimedia.org https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikimedia-in-en