Hello. I'd like to get some feedback about how Wikispecies is going.
It's difficult to tell from looking at the pages here whether the
project is going well or not. Specifically, I'd like answers to the
following:
1. Is there duplication with Wikipedia, and if so, how is that
being dealt with? Have policies been created to ensure Wikispecies
will not be a fork of Wikipedia?
2. Is data from here having any use within Wikipedia?
3. Are there unresolved language issues? Should Wikispecies be
available in other languages or are measures needed to make sure the
project is multilingually useful within the same wiki?
4. Are users applying standard templates to new pages? If so, will
these be easy to adapt to wikidata format
(<http://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/wikidata>) when that becomes
available?
5. Are there any technical measures needed to make this project useful?
6. Do you feel this project needs to be separate, or would
combining it with Wikipedia, Wikibooks, or even the Wikimedia Commons,
make more sense?
7. This wiki was supposed to provide a solution to the problem that
there is no central registration of species data. Do you feel the wiki
in its current state does help to solve this?
8. Wikispecies was supposed to be aimed at the needs of scientific
users rather than general users. Is this still the case? Does this aim
still seem the best approach for this project?
9. Does the Wikispecies Charter still seem viable?
http://species.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikispecies:Wikispecies_Charter
10. The Wikispecies FAQ I wrote at
http://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wikispecies_FAQ noted that Wikispecies
was still in the discussion stage. Do you feel it has evolved past
this point now?
Thanks.
Angela.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Angela