[WikiEN-l] A narrower concept of boldness

Ken Arromdee arromdee at rahul.net
Thu Jun 7 14:01:13 UTC 2007


On Thu, 7 Jun 2007, Tony Sidaway wrote:
> Ignore all rules regularly fills up with useless encrustations of
> rubbish and needs emptying out.  You too can help with this.  The only
> wording you need is  that it's Wikipedia policy and it goes something
> like "If the rules stop you improving Wikipedia, ignore them."  Just
> toss all the rest out.

This fails utterly.  The usual method of abuse is for someone to say "that
doesn't count as improving Wikipedia".  Usually this means someone claims that
1) some other rule defines what it means to improve Wikipedia (at which point
IAR becomes useless, of course), or 2) external considerations like not
harming BLP subjects don't "improve Wikipedia" since they don't help readers
of Wikipedia articles.




More information about the WikiEN-l mailing list