[WikiEN-l] cancelation of the deletion review of the satanism userbox
macgyvermagic at gmail.com
Wed May 31 21:26:37 UTC 2006
Exactly how does allowing a userbox for people to show they're a satanist
puts Wikipedia in disrepute? We've got userboxes for multiple beliefs and
life styles and satanism is just another to add to the bunch. You act as if
satanism is bad. Perhaps you should read the article on the subject. Just
the lead alone is quite informative.
Besides, it's not exactly a secret we don't select editors on their beliefs.
Deleting one userbox because people mis-associate it with something they
consider evil will only promote ignorance.
Either cut all religious userboxes or keep them all, don't start getting
selective. The box is just as useful as a "I am a Christian"-box. Disrepute
due to beliefs is only an issue if said editors consistently misbehave.
People worry too much over userboxes. Either take the above suggestion and
make general boxes, or simply make one now and stop the proliferation.
On 5/31/06, Tony Sidaway <f.crdfa at gmail.com> wrote:
> this was a deletion review, with a view to restoration, of a userbox
> that said the owner was a satanist. I have canceled it on the grounds
> that such a template could only bring the project into disrepute.
> I'm confident that this is best for Wikipedia. I don't think the goal
> of producing a high quality encyclopedia can be served by encouraging,
> though the provision of templates saying "I'm a satanist" and the
> like, the use of Wikipedia's website for social networking and
> coordination of work between adherents of satanism. It could only
> bring the whole enterprise into disrepute to permit such abuse.
> Therefore it's inappropriate to hold a DRV-style debate where
> traditionally the item is restored if a certain proportion of editors
> vote to restore it. We cannot make such a decision on the basis of
> votes. Perhaps a discussion on the talk page of the template might be
> appropriate, though I think it would require a very strong case to be
> made for this particular template
> WikiEN-l mailing list
> WikiEN-l at Wikipedia.org
> To unsubscribe from this mailing list, visit:
More information about the WikiEN-l