2007/3/14, Daniel Arnold arnomane@gmx.de:
Well especially a simple flag unsetting can't work within a wiki (regardless which one). Flag unsetting feature is equal to quality vote wars.
Yes, this danger is there. And you are right for the sighted-flag, but not for reviewed, as there the flag has a lot of meaning. Therefore, it should be possible to remove the flag in case of errors. I believe if the reviewer participate in "flag-wars", then the choice of reviewers is to blame and not the feature.
Hm all my comments are based on the feature set and specifications that were discussed about in public and which are written down in the de.wikipedia wiki. Are these the same? I am a bit confused.
These are nearly the same. The exact feature set that Erik and I decided on and that Joerg will implement is described in Eriks mail to this list from 28. Februar 2007 17:36.
It is essentialy what is written in de.wikipedia, but more precise in some parts, for example regarding templates and is a bit more flexible in some parts, for example in stating that there will be not 2, but multiple flags possible.
Bye,
Philipp