Cool. I was impressed to the point of being shocked at how small VP9 was
able to make one of my videos at 1080p.
Commons video playback improvements in Edge would be very welcome.
On Wed, Apr 13, 2016 at 12:41 PM, Brion Vibber <bvibber(a)wikimedia.org>
In addition to the smaller bandwidth requirements for
VP9 video encoding
versus Theora or VP8, Microsoft is adding support for VP9 video and Opus
audio in WebM to Windows 10 in the summer 2016 update.
Currently in Win10 preview builds this only works in Edge when using Media
Source Extensions, and VP9 is disabled by default if not
hardware-accelerated, but it's coming along. :)
If the final version lands with suitable config, users of Edge version 15
playback on Wikipedia. Neat!
Things still to do in TimedMediaHandler:
* add transcode output for audio-only files as Opus in WebM container
* keep working on the Kaltura->VideoJS front-end switch to make our lives
easier fixing the UI (Derk-Jan & Brion) and to prep for...
* eventually we'll want to use MPEG-DASH manifests and Media Source
Extensions to implement playback that's responsive to network and CPU speed
and can switch resolutions seamlessly. This may or may not be a
prerequisite for Win10 Edge playback if MS sticks with the MSE requirement.
* consider improving the transcode status overview at
Special:TimedMediaHandler; it reports errors in a way that doesn't scale
Things still to do in Wikimedia site config:
* add VP9/Opus transcodes to our config (audio, 240p, 360p, 480p, 720p,
1080p definitely; consider 1440p and 2160p for Ultra-HD videos)
* consider dropping some VP8 sizes (desktop browsers that support VP8
should all support VP9 now; old Android versions that don't grok VP9 might
be main target remaining for VP8)
Things to consider:
* VP9 is slower to encode than VP8, and a transition will require a lot of
back-running of existing files. We *will* need to assign more video
scalers, at least temporarily.
* I started writing a client-side bot to trigger new transcodes on old
files. Prefer I should finish that, or prep a server side script that
someone in ops will have to babysit?
* in future, the ogv.js JS decoder shim will still be used for Safari and
IE 11, but I may be able to shift it from Theora to VP9 after making more
fixes to the WebM demuxer. Decoding is slower per pixel but at a lower
resolution you often get higher quality because of better compression and
handling of motion -- and bandwidth usage is much better, which should make
it a win on iPhones. This means eventually we may be able to reduce or drop
the Ogg output. This will also tie in with MPEG-DASH adaptive streaming, so
should be able to pick best size for CPU speed more reliably than current
* longer term, AOMedia codec will arrive (initial code drop came out
recently, based on VP10) with definite support from Google, Mozilla, and
Microsoft. This should end up supplementing VP9 in a couple years, and
should be even more bandwidth-efficient for high resolutions.
Multimedia mailing list