[Wikipedia-l] National Public Radio (US): "Wikipedia's Growth Comes with Concerns"

David Monniaux David.Monniaux at ens.fr
Mon Feb 21 06:55:39 UTC 2005


 > The new Britannica FUD was interesting: Their new take is that 
Wikipedia is too detailed and one of the things that makes EB great is 
that they make careful

Well, I think that some of Wikipedia's articles suffer from imbalances 
and lack of focus. This is probably the result of cooperative editing 
without restructuring:
- when there's an "edit war" on a particular aspect of the topic, this 
aspect usually gets documented by quotes, references etc by both 
parties, leading to an inflated coverage of the opinions surrounding 
this aspect
- some editors have pet peeves and will over-document whatever is 
related to it.




More information about the Wikipedia-l mailing list