[Wikipedia-l] Wikicite project pages (english versions only so far)

Stan Shebs shebs at apple.com
Wed Feb 9 22:59:01 UTC 2005


Mark Williamson wrote:

>Whenever somebody adds a random cite to an article written mostly or
>entirely by me, I remove it unless I actually DID use that source.
>
So no one is allowed to touch the article references section except
yourself? That's a little possessive, to say the least. Suppose I
check your claims against my reference, find them good, see no reason
to change the text, and add the reference as a token that I've done
the checking?

References are there for *other* people to use; if you've neglected
to mention the standard text that readers should look at if they want
to know more, then other editors need to be able to fix your mistake.

By your reasoning, we could never add to the references section
for an article written two years ago by someone who has since moved
on, nor could a 1911EB-derived article ever get updated references,
at least not without casting a resurrection spell first...

Stan




More information about the Wikipedia-l mailing list