[Wikipedia-l] wikipedia is too much open

[Pablo De Nápoli]

Hi!

I'm new to wikipedia, and I think that it is a great project that can help to 
extend the ideas of free software to other areas, and to non technical 
people. 

I don't want to start a flame war but I want to express my point of view on 
the way that articles are edited in wikipedia.

I've contributed with some articles. I'm rather disapointed, though. For 
example, I've rewriten the article on Lebesgue integration in the English 
wikipedia, since I find that the article explained the tenichal difficulties 
of Riemman integral, but it does not define the notion of Lebesgue integral
(perhaps I had to tell you that I'm a mathematician, I work at the mathematics 
department of Buenos Aires University, Argentina).

After that, looking at the history of the page, I find that some rather old 
previous versions where much better, but they had been deleted since a
user consider them "too advanced". Needless to say, Lebesgue integration is 
indeed an advanced topic in mathematics, so that any article on this subject 
is necesarilly advanced (or does not covered the topic).

It seems to me that the model of  wikipedia is too much open, so that open 
that anyone can annonymously edit any page. That I think is to much.that at 
least one should have to register and log in in order to modify a page, one 
has to take a responsability for what is saying (specially for deleting some 
one else work). In the current model, we don't know who write what
(even though, most civilizated wiikipedians do log in, but I think this should 
be mandatory)

Another idea that comes to my mind is that there could be some teams for 
especific topics, that  manage the pages in some section (say mathematics, 
geogrpahy, 
economics or whatever). This does not mean that any user from outside the team 
could not submit modifications. But without a team of core developers or 
a project leader for each section how can you assure a minimum of
quality of wikipedia?
(this is more or less the model in all free software projects, no project 
grants write access to cvs to everyone anonymously, say)

Best regards,
Pablo De Nápoli