[WikiEN-l] Daniel Brandt

Trebor Rowntree trebor.rowntree at gmail.com
Fri Feb 23 17:04:55 UTC 2007


Frankly, two and a half hours for a DRV is bordering on the ridiculous. Very
few people have the opportunity to see it and form opinions in this time;
hell, a lot of them won't even be awake. This was a vastly out of process
speedy deletion, considering the article had survived so many AfDs. But we
could perhaps consider it to be in the spirit of IAR. But you don't then
justify an out of process deletion with an out of process speedy
endorsement. Discussion is _not_ bad. All this does is cause more and more
discussion over the nature of the closure, and less and less on the issue
(and thus even _less_ attention goes on the rest of the encyclopaedia).
Jimbo commented on the Peppers DRV "As I say, I think it would have been
slightly better to let it run for at least 24 hours"; this is going in the
opposite direction.
Trebor


More information about the WikiEN-l mailing list