[WikiEN-l] Guardian article about Wikipedia

[charles matthews]

Stephen Bain wrote

>The guy looking at the entry on TS Eliot was critical because it
didn't list his book in the bibliography. I think that's certainly an
unfair criticism.

No.  He (Anthony Julius) mentioned that his book wasn't included as a 
reference.  He didn't make this a criticism.  (If the article went deeply 
into the Eliot-anti-Semitism row, it should mention the book, which is a 
thorough survey of what the row is about).

Some of these comments about the Guardian seem far too defensive.

Charles