[WikiEN-l] Re: A neo-Nazi wikipedia

El C el.ceeh at gmail.com
Mon Aug 29 03:59:41 UTC 2005


> I consider the Amelekite case to be in the same genre, although slightly
(but only slightly) less obvious.

>--Jimbo

Yes. And it is not in the spirit of Wikipedia, in my opinion, to view
this "slightly less obvious" dimension as a total amensty for that
user, as "the same genre," esp. vis-a-vis the distress felt by the
victims.

Another unfortunate and un-contextual current of thought claims
non-Jews (or non-Jimbos) are or stand the risk of being treated more
poorly (unequally). But I maintain that evidence needs to be submitted
with specific examples in order to identify and undertake the
necessary corrections.

At the event, I am only familliar with two offsite hate and/or hit
lists: this one, and the Sollog one. It's crucial, then, to remain
more-or-less grounded to what is actually taking place, as opposed to
abstract ideals.

El_C



More information about the WikiEN-l mailing list