[WikiEN-l] Three or four problems (Plautus)

Poor, Edmund W Edmund.W.Poor at abc.com
Fri Feb 20 15:20:13 UTC 2004


Plautus,

1. I figured out today why your posts were being "held for moderation".
It's because you've been e-mailing them to the following addresses:

  English at mail.wikimedia.org; 
  Wikipedia at mail.wikimedia.org

Please use wikien-l at Wikipedia.org instead.

2. If there's a choice between preserving context and /quoting someone
out of context/ I'm sure you know which is the better choice. But you
can also simply add your comments at the end of the talk page. Like, "I
think this article should mention beanbag chairs more prominently!" Why
bother to quote others at all, if it's bringing trouble you way?

3. No one has a "right to instantly revert" -- with the possible of
exception of the edits of a hard-banned user. Try to avoid tit-for-tat
thinking: it won't get you anywhere.

4. You wrote, "Having to continually and constantly defend each and
every single edit, no matter how trivial, is really tiresome." If this
has been your experience lately, why not try something that has always
worked for me? Take some time to think about how other contributors
might view your proposed edit; then word it so that they would be
unlikely to object to it. It's not easy to work this way, but it pays
off in the long run.

Best wishes,

Ed Poor, aka Uncle Ed

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://lists.wikimedia.org/pipermail/wikien-l/attachments/20040220/5b4113dc/attachment.htm 


More information about the WikiEN-l mailing list