[Foundation-l] Is popularity a good thing for us?
chiesa.marco at gmail.com
Mon Dec 17 08:50:50 UTC 2007
Thomas Dalton ha scritto:
> It's an excellent point. I thought about it a few months ago and
> considered proposing a new policy banning anything under a week old
> from being included in Wikipedia articles (actually, it was a little
> more complicated than that, but that's the gist of it). It would help
> Wikinews, and would also reduce the number of articles which are a
> succession of "As June 2006 ..." paragraphs. Current events are not
> encyclopaedic and it's impossible to write a good encyclopaedia
> article as soon as something happens, since all the required sources
> haven't been written yet (you have a handful of newspaper articles
> which you can simply rewrite and that's it). I ended up not proposing
> it because I didn't think I was enthusiastic enough about it to
> survive the torture of trying to get it approved. Anyone think it's
> worth a shot?
You are absolutely wrong here. Such a policy exists. On the Italian
Wikipedia, we do not accept articles on things happened less than 2
weeks ago. Each project has different policies, and this is NOT the
place where policies about a SINGLE project should be discussed. If you
want to compare policies it's probably ok, but for your own policies go
to your own mailing lists, please.
More information about the foundation-l