Ok, the John Smith disambig page is absolutely hysterical to me....
James Alexander Community Advocacy Wikimedia Foundation (415) 839-6885 x6716 @jamesofur
On Wed, Aug 12, 2015 at 2:35 PM, Katherine Maher kmaher@wikimedia.org wrote:
This disambiguation thing is pretty funny. We should do something with it at some point :)
---------- Forwarded message ---------- From: Beutler Ink hello@beutlerink.com Date: Wed, Aug 12, 2015 at 8:00 AM Subject: WP:60 • Week 38 | Anti-Disambiguation-arianism To: katherine@wikimedia.org
Zen and the art of topical disambiguation
[image: WP:60, a weekly Wikipedia newsletter from Beutler Ink] http://t.hsms10.com/e1t/c/*W1sCvKq5_zhZ-W2hDMWz4Dth9D0/*W5R4wjx51HfvKVrV71c1bJ5nN0/5/f18dQhb0Sjvd8XJ888W8jkN972qwv1yW2stjD_2shjyLMf57MsXD6prW39Dr-N8pCDKkW6bL3GG69_jjkW7Z5GVw6PXLp3W6PVKcr6N3nBLW8xGZPk5Dz8spW69NG0_7_5Rt7W7c7F4f1njGYlW56Qnq996zRPSW6bT6L38RRjRDW5Ckvrl1fdmXTW3Kz8t05m3ZGGW96dt4S4r1QvYW35ZzJq8gjY6LW8WBKbV56sy_8W2NhXFJ1BqmN1V6F0BG9gH-JhW12KhV75KYCCSW2d54Th2fqZfMW5p5Qwy2K5pPvW7s2l4R58ymSCW2MzGYR1WbNKwW82C9Yd9cyqGjW2SF3Ht312jztN7Lq2B370dVtN6yBk5DHqX_9N7qb8HQrpXqkN4lBZ6FnpD5TW1Q68w61MMh8vW25k-Xt1s5WDFW4F1GMq2XZYlBW7kLSB495S7zbVsk4dR3BBkFLW6ZJhPp8FxhzPW2B65ly3c5r13W2bR4mn5_71wBW3kSM3M34vb7TW1tGQJT4L0hC0f2qdtJT04 [image: Beutler_WP60_logo_blog]
Hi Katherine, Welcome to Week 38: "Anti-Disambiguation-arianism"
• • •
Disambiguation is a concept that got little public attention before Wikipedia (like the @ symbol was little-used before email). When a Wikipedia article needs a title http://t.hsms10.com/e1t/c/*W1sCvKq5_zhZ-W2hDMWz4Dth9D0/*W2Ll-Vx4vNSJ4W1n9Scp9lMGmL0/5/f18dQhb0Sq5F8YHrlsW8jkN972qwv1yW2stjD_2shjyLMf57bRXD6prW39DrXV6bL3GGW69_jjk7Z5nq9W6RwTBw6b-xmrN96Lsb1bGbydN8p180kc97nyW51S7QV5CnpkWW8nWjdD90G7thN8S3yR5bY02SW4s8d3z1nJ8cBW8pmbSQ1mhW2DW3Vpgs_96zRPSW6bT6L38RRjRDW5Ckvrl3Lpx8sW4j6Ww-5m3ZGGW96dt4S4r1QvYW6yGFm77cvxVfN8q5qBxVQf4XW5vDhTY8lG2_KW5zK1wl3HwqkHW2CfWV26MjZCgW8qC4dg2DmF5QW64KRvQ10y2NjW1mbSdy8t34sTW8tyf2Y8p_T1WW24Xk6r8p047bW5G80Tk2zgZ6vW7dFbvJ1pGnlkW3Gv64L35WrMMW2D69S362LXX0N8GclM4PNmfhW3Cdk0d3wv7SmW4bGymk2TffRxVMcqz12YDvqsW6Gn-jV6_98lRW2nRzM357_lMyVS-Wy82fcfKmW1vhnSS3X2_2hW8sB1k25rbrmGN7shYpxmRw0WV9ZLfD6318kF111, but another topic already is using that name, what do you do? By devising a method to reduce the ambiguity.
What Wikipedia usually does is adds parentheses after the formal title, selecting a phrase that most closely describes what is unique about each one. For example, several dozen John Smiths have met Wikipedia's notability http://t.hsms10.com/e1t/c/*W1sCvKq5_zhZ-W2hDMWz4Dth9D0/*W6jCgGZ3shYJsN23qrqlJ-DdJ0/5/f18dQhb0SbTP8Y9YsWW7fz3SM4T_wzgW4WYDf-4WzD5sMsc-tTXD6prW39DrXV6bL3GGW69_jjk7Z5nq9W6RwTBw6b-xmrN96Lsb1bGbydW4sGQp72JcGqXW1n8D_Z1nrCGBW51LTg55DHNj2N8f6Z_Bc97nyW51_Pz58pmbSQW1mhW2D3Vpgs_W96zRPS6bT6L3W8RRjRD5CktzDW3nN9mn3ndm6jW49WVtr3VVg3wW3ynQc-6G2lbzN7NMdQN4cNXyW75WRHJ7s7N2jW78wSdg3-YSSPW1Lsydc3p1NxRW7JHnqw6sk3JTW7qjJqH1tkn4WW4lVRlg9knPdhW7s4r_b82JN3YW2DQ0Hx6xPrWsW78FfRw8T2vSRW5KJ3_P7sp1sqW6jqYxY9dys33N31JGMGkydxlW5gSHY56H5W2lW37P0d415hnZlW2ZYdB87ZcFxkW53vw_s14P6T2V5n9vD1McdTkW4J35Sn2N3DcwW84dr_J5vrx8jW773tGT8jKykPW5fYrGD3Hst_RW3zZTd75DYklbVrKGtg5qJfGrf3wqTQq04 requirement, so there are no less than six cricketers and seven footballers disambiguated only by their birth date http://t.hsms10.com/e1t/c/*W1sCvKq5_zhZ-W2hDMWz4Dth9D0/*W3j2ygq4TWy-bW75gT78502Q9N0/5/f18dQhb0SbTY8YHrCHW8jkN972qwv1yW2stjD_2shjyLVf5c9R57mvFqW3BJFQw7MN5VxW7vl0GW7NrMWRW6YTq0R4zN4xVW1BkNFr2gNgHQW1ly7qx1ksGJhW1R4_lX1V5BRbW12xxk_1M7k4-W1slWZl6DHVvxW5Y46-41tmXX4W5-2t5m20WxtkW36dP-r68QsSXW1-ZK0j2Y7Dl7W6pzHWB79p91kW2tk5vH2z_scnW6x2RKS5-lMJcW5sSp7n42cwz1W32Qq896259wZW2V2YQh6z0w46W4GmGLN6fYnD_W6K1l4d4LXb4qW3Rp5fR6tTH_tW35bn_S41CC5LW3xjbFy41JfjTW2N9l0N2_2hjwW6NMRTS70l0z4W50WdSP47T_26W5gWV4P3Xzwy4W82G-VB8yL2YnW4Ps9ks3BJsgQVcZLWR86kZnlW8SlcC657T_pbW6VBJ892nmCsmW1YD4481Ngx1fW519-Yt9bvYP1N6xM5dVVprGVW3pm8MR8ScDwSW56nkzB3-h57mW32N7N95WGdW8W2qVp1X39GZgM0 .
And all relevant examples (including similar spellings) are collected on a single page, the disambiguation page. One of my favorite ironies of Wikipedia: disambiguation has its own disambiguation page, naturally found at Disambiguation (disambiguation) http://t.hsms10.com/e1t/c/*W1sCvKq5_zhZ-W2hDMWz4Dth9D0/*W75bFpS1cfry2W1BccM750kptm0/5/f18dQhb0Sq5H8YXMxCW8jkN972qwv1yW2stjD_2shjyLMf5b0xXD6prW7cmS1s6bnWj5W5Dz8sp69NG0_W4vFpLQ97x8_0W2MND6F41HphRW3SYgR64DlgB4W2LhNXg4QzxvkW3SLYcb49JfBwW3C8bwH40vph_W5cBvfd4rDgrjN2HCrMJ-zhhVW47YlYy4bfcHbW47Xx4z3C811XW4-THSY8cBYyyW2Hyb609dH8_6W6V4mf74q_dR4W8gjY6L8WBKbVW56sy_82NhXK3W31_yWq2Pxs5JW2M_8s-4ctR6kW4hLQnT8SQ-JnW9fGlZ94dtdHGW7sD2X-2qz4kSW4BKvqL52QCnfW9cLSD02rjLRzW2NdXXC9dKXdtVLmFDf7JdQf2MsQHGZ67PNyW4c0nqh7J-VTmW30rlZV4lBZ6FVnpxyl1Q68w6W1MMh8v25k-XtN1s5WGPRbrg5W27r3hz6M7gtQW2-PWWW4QDgwJVWWh6w1LXY17W4xp2S82-zmd3W7R5yCZ7C0LfVW1tjsrt5wwTW4MNDyx-mXsvhf8QzgLJ11 .
• • •
*Missed any previous installments of WP:60? Never fear! You can catch up with the WP:60 archive http://t.hsms10.com/e1t/c/*W1sCvKq5_zhZ-W2hDMWz4Dth9D0/*W7zL_9J1LxtqbN2R2SJ9wwMDJ0/5/f18dQhb0Sjvk8XJ91zW8jkN972qwv1yW2stjD_2shjyLMf5gNKXD6prW39DrXV6bL3GGW69_jjk7Z5nq9W6RwTBw6b-xmrN96Lsb1bGby8W61SSZm7mG7sDW51vX4y6HSkXLW5BXZfr5CY-dqW6cc-4t69LPZ7W2x-2mC203WCyN2yJF1WYT2jkW6P4lCX3WddQjW6NwVrr6Pr3nqW1Tcntw1njMtBW6H5Dht53X_ZpW52Ylfx3_8mplW9fgwMT4fd9F2V5Wpjs8WByytW30QxWc7qzx16W31M2m249G66MW6YdfGn7xrqV3W2Qc5gm3288KtN7qN2YCH8BpsW1SDvK92NmSDXW5Lng4F8h2QFJW1Fx5rx77VQt3W2Kl_121GjbfLVnLJys1VJGwxW7p3C-_3MYtL8W80Pmlj1NFfl4W8P4m4R515PkWW3GJ1rf2HYFPZW98j6-Q5vvztgW5YxPJW1wRS6NW5cthdm1Y3cTTW6LPXTQ72ccG_W85b1xl5HPZhQW3DhQNG5nxK7sW1NwBMj1MKdbSf1QnWvB11.*
*Next week: Autobiography* Why not share WP:60 with a friend? [image: Share on Facebook] http://t.hsms10.com/e1t/c/*W1sCvKq5_zhZ-W2hDMWz4Dth9D0/*W8kVd0l3JZ28RW3Cxp8Q69bKmJ0/5/f18dQhb0SmhS9cKtMhW24y60Y1m65mSN1hJHjcqhj4KW5_jkHS1mhDGsW99c0JB8nP3syW7mWgWk96-z6SN96Ls9rYnPL7W4sMN_m90Gn9TW1y0jc45cvsmdW2mqQZ95wk1VzW3jgTWc3jL12VW6dTKxs38qgn6VCQ8QC3sHxjbW30XKxR3W-gZCW5lhgkJ5F_2JdW6gcY7M5L1GMpW5B93d87d_5gmW5KxXB65JVr24W3k5LfK5VcW6bW5pfvqL5hjb6FW3NrNBZ5MsRm2N5rk93t-PpcgW3TqxMQ2-294gW5J0bHm1zmYKWW3wMqpl5mgZxGW5mg0gg3XWp-yW8XZrps4yc3CKW3sSDqD5kmcLGW2Jb9PJ4wfnQ9W315H4R2X52K-W5CDrTh2WrQvpW6QJJpb4DXPfGW3z1gJZ6JQFNPW4ngglH4D7jDLW3F6Ptk3bYmTpW5nyH713VP_rRW5jFX5L4tSgMpW2xJXtt6H2NYlW6xy_0h5FFn61W6mVCWf421SMdW6p0MKL73DCThVcWbVf4Wpz-0Vg9mC879SV2pW4PYpPT8nl49yW4yTZgr3vBB9qW19rcTf7gxVzzW55y9tt15DzlpVM7WGL6F4r0cW4dhwD82KCq-0N3L7-8p9XfyRV3_BYG5n5nKP111 [image: Share on LinkedIn] http://t.hsms10.com/e1t/c/*W1sCvKq5_zhZ-W2hDMWz4Dth9D0/*W1HD1T874syQbW3wt0pG2-CyW90/5/f18dQhb0S5fw9c-mG2W7fz3SM4T_wzgW4WYDf-4WzD5sVsc-HM1SddPTW6kfX-L7s5Q50W1TxM8G328yYnW5mZ50N54GbQNW3015gP1SPJ3xW8HwrsB1SvQy0W2KGkn6557zBLW3jdmzy36Qv3TW1tk8v93tQxPXN6Brpbfk4lygVSJmvT3xbYbQW5xF6285nLW-lW3jSCxR38nHSfW5QQxWp1Xg-fbW61_zby1V0ndSW7jKkzY5KxXB6W5JVr2p3-FnkfMl1-6vQJ99nW8tsM4B3M2F92W8ZJ0Rc62K-C6W6rBRvq1vBXDlW7hYCG43N1M0FW1Ptq101RlPJ4W6cKf1y5tg24_W7WnVk04FxQYfVRFkK45G18KhW3y9KYQ3dgtKGW18Zyth8vWw4sW31YV_P3mLgbdVRBHcf5PZFrLW35tXtP5BJ7ZMW5HF-L68vX-wVW31D3cF8DwXc4VHf-hC8DSBsMW3crd625mXh54W2-0DXG8h43cwW5mg5Dh3cT5DhW8xwBS43B_hdJW31yYpW6wydXJMQBrNxrPpMvMrJh2DxljDZN50ChNMd5J_-W8nkX0-42LvbxW5xHh6g714h8ZW1ny0Sz8KH8p9W7qNvkq3yyt6KW48mgGW7hxVwXW1Sdf2h6s2BQ9W2Q-8H54Wq2YxW1S35g06rgB4d0 [image: Share on Twitter] http://t.hsms10.com/e1t/c/*W1sCvKq5_zhZ-W2hDMWz4Dth9D0/*W4Q-ZKb6VwFpsW8hvVKq8gc9800/5/f18dQhb0S1Wb7Bf-yPW12P3KC1pVBNgW3x_qVM80mhM5W97yv7W80TjNVW40gzWm417_8yW4STGSk8YKjVDW3M6dL7807zCwVmtKpl73Rgs9W8btCcT3cbZp4W2cjTh28R92p_N78VH5Sh1ZVpW12SBg4836Pc2W4DBN0L6b84M2W7Rsfr29091cqVC6f_m1RYl36W4_tpDX1SrsLKW60FdBg7vxv5lW78cHvn5gb3h6W2JdFL08787LfVvrfpn8zS3K-W1fpgvZ8B_BB-W3k5kld51gyd1W5sWb3x70W-xMW7fH83J1jWjTsW7rdvJ-3nBWmFW3nGlL22JnkM7W89X7Rn2VY214W2c8bwP3_RM0ZM1BMHjy5SH6W6bTFwL8lZLBNW1BL3mS1DkRWYN3s7YHZ_SNXBW1Hbwj84PZNXCMsRs0FQzr2YV9XbqB5w20_FW32TWTl14SM2tN4NGcWX4gJgZW7ZG_TG7jV0vFW9j_jZj15p2jrW1T_9Dt2W_NPKW5MRC0Z52lXqpW2YHrqr8fd_NfW8H8JJs4QLqFBW40WBjS992vMQW5XjWsS6F-NCYW156w7G8K1T4nW5Bbrry40L73-W3c7bTl5-XmrDW38nFN78kt-DjW3NFxWJ8JMT-KW8KryD34RYF1sW4QlcjW69PvCzW9d-jHm68xWmVW1Lzjm51JSWrbW5vYVVv3MnFZfN2hy_Z-T5KsyW6NrSVF978MkkW7nrFdr7jvt4WW8y67w13wnVtSW9fLgXt4tJXngW8Nn01n5bJsf9W8ZgK6Q9cd5lj0 [image: Share on Google+] http://t.hsms10.com/e1t/c/*W1sCvKq5_zhZ-W2hDMWz4Dth9D0/*W2RfNd62GLBWTW6NS9fT7Nm0bX0/5/f18dQhb0Smh_4y9PLtW24y60Y1m65mSN1hJHjcqhj4KW5-3LM51mhDJwW39DrWD25M7lFW8yGlqJ25NHJ3N96Ls9rYnPL7W90GbdD6H9RBfW82Lp0D36Qv3TW1tk8v93tQxPXW6Brpbf1tk8tSW5_L_Cg3sctSKW5RVTFY5KYzdFW5lNvG88FjVBdW10w9KP5lN3kkW3W-gDT5RY2zRW5-rlcH1vc49zN3v7CBPmVXdGW7wgg6c6j7L5XW5rWxMz7sTjsdW2Qy-df7C0l7bTRd-d8_xl22W37sPV-6sSysYW2XsCWx7tfTGBN2PLSJQM60qvW7zN65h1CcfkCW8lRBhw2Fq95DW22WLyB6HBHnDW6qG7347VRYShW7YBLLb1tmTXKW7m3g7Y7c3hqfW1bNFXX1bTmRVW1lC4HN7JTFgHW5XXRJX2d30P1W7qcn8V7jZtMHW6k1Zx07XrYwlW1x87DP796DzRW7DPWNK7YqQ_8W6lTrDD7vMfDFW5ZbVJb23N9NTW13_CLR64TT97W58m_sr4PxC8jW448frN4pHS2tW4XFXXg6cYTsMW8RCj3n1lSrj3W61FQxn7mtWScW2cST028ynf4QVvtHrG5vTQb_W5QFgBv8FSHHlW7KMlTy9cPbSwN2pgj481-MVzf5kZmfB02 [image: Share on Email] <?subject=Check+out+http%3A%2F%2Finfo.beutlerink.com%2Fwp60_newsletter%3Futm_medium%3Dsocial%26utm_source%3Demail+&body=Check+out+http%3A%2F%2Finfo.beutlerink.com%2Fwp60_newsletter%3Futm_medium%3Dsocial%26utm_source%3Demail>
Beutler Ink 1629 Columbia Rd. NW Suite 433 Washington, DC 20009 USA
You received this email because you are subscribed to Wikipedia in 60 Seconds from Beutler Ink.
-- Katherine Maher Chief Communications Officer Wikimedia Foundation 149 New Montgomery Street San Francisco, CA 94105
+1 (415) 839-6885 ext. 6635 +1 (415) 712 4873 kmaher@wikimedia.org
Social-media mailing list Social-media@lists.wikimedia.org https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/social-media