Responses below.
-greg
On Aug 13, 2015, at 12:57 AM, James Alexander jalexander@wikimedia.org wrote:
Thoughts inline
James Alexander Community Advocacy Wikimedia Foundation (415) 839-6885 x6716 @jamesofur
On Wed, Aug 12, 2015 at 9:38 AM, Tilman Bayer <tbayer@wikimedia.org mailto:tbayer@wikimedia.org> wrote: from @wikipedia and @mediawiki: https://twitter.com/wikidata/status/631460768249200641 https://twitter.com/wikidata/status/631460768249200641
No real issues from mediawiki but this one worries me a bit from @wikipedia. It just sounds a bit too technical/inside baseball. Even I read it and went "arbitrary access? WTF is that?" before thinking harder and realizing they mean being able to call within templates etc. I worry that the vast majority of our audience would have no idea what this is.
Agree that it is appropriate for @mw - seems less so for @wp
from @wikipedia: https://twitter.com/WikimediaCH/status/626066626308407296 https://twitter.com/WikimediaCH/status/626066626308407296
Fine by me as long as we're ok with calling it Wikipedia's medical encyclopedia (possibly implying it's an official app?).
I’m on the fence about these personally - has mobile weighed in on these set of apps?
from @wikicommons and perhaps others: https://twitter.com/benglabs/status/629966289574957056 https://twitter.com/benglabs/status/629966289574957056 https://twitter.com/Pyb75/status/629670299580125185 https://twitter.com/Pyb75/status/629670299580125185
LGTM
LGTM from @wc and @wp - maybe @wm
from @mediawiki, the first one perhaps also from @wikipedia: https://twitter.com/brionv/status/629733830547509248 https://twitter.com/brionv/status/629733830547509248
mayyyybe from @wikipedia, fairly technical though. @mediawiki for sure
https://twitter.com/brionv/status/630384030509207552 https://twitter.com/brionv/status/630384030509207552
LGTM for @mediawiki
+1 for just @mw only
from @wikimedia and perhaps others: https://twitter.com/danjarratt/status/631139320997392385 https://twitter.com/danjarratt/status/631139320997392385
LGTM for @wikimedia/@wikipedia/@wikicommons
+1 for all three
Social-media mailing list Social-media@lists.wikimedia.org https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/social-media