Hi,
If we poke roles in the firewall so Icinga can reach the VMs and we define the monitoring::service stuff in Puppet, is that all we need to shutdown Shinken? Do you think there would be any concerns with going that route?
I'm asking about this because soon we'll see requests about removing more and more Jessie support from the Puppet codebase [0] and there's no exit strategy from Jessie for Shinken (it's not available in Stretch unless we want to package things ourselves, which I tried and failed).
0 - https://gerrit.wikimedia.org/r/c/operations/puppet/+/491460
Thanks,