[WikiEN-l] Re: Another AfD example -- a serious proposal to fix it

[Phil Boswell]

"Kat Walsh" <mindspillage at gmail.com> wrote in 
message news:8e253f560601201327gbd28a80v3b8d847e9c0c0f3e at mail.gmail.com...
[snip]
> I also like the idea of "speedy keep" being more widely used; if
> someone comes up with a really strong justification for why something
> should not be deleted, particularly if it completely rebuts the
> nominator's reason for nominating it, why waste time arguing about it?

Hmmm.

Isn't this what SnowSpinner's {{user recovery}} template was esentially all 
about?

Or am I getting confused with his "expertise and deletion" notice?

> Perhaps this is what a "deletion cabal" could do: simply make the call
> to speedy pull a nomination, rather than penalize the nominator. I'd
> imagine anyone whose nominations were continually getting pulled for
> being inappropriate would eventually start to think about them more,
> no penalty necessary.

I'd think anyone who nominations were getting pulled that often should be 
considered for a WP:POINT time-out...

HTH HAND
-- 
Phil
[[en:User:Phil Boswell]]