@ Shyamal
Thanks for your reply. Thanks for referring to CC0 documentation. Those who are already
following this discussion thread can refer to 1st and last point i.e. 1) & 4 D) and
ofcourse the disclaimer.
1) The main purpose of document meta:Help:Form I & Affidavit (Customised for
relinquishment of copyright as per 'free cultural work' definition) is, uitlise
available provisions-processess for copyright relinqushment under Indian Copyright law.
2) At the same time comply with the law and spirit of 'free cultural work
definition' to the best possible extant.
Legal aspect in the free cultural work definition is, "No other restrictions or
limitations: The work itself must not be covered by legal restrictions ....or limitations
.... which would impede the freedoms enumerated ... . A work may make use of existing
legal exemptions to copyright (in order to cite copyrighted works), though only the
portions of it which are unambiguously free constitute a free work. "
3) As issue raised by me at meta rfc I feel there is a need to revisit clause by clause;
Section 21 subsection (3), Section 30A, Section 19 subsections 1,2,4,5,6; Section 57
subsection(1) clause (b) of Indian Copyright Act 1957, to be inline with spirit of
'free cultural work definition'
4 A) Now you suggested to refer to CC0 I feel the same to be ok enough vis a vis Section
57 (1) b;
4 B) If words legal tool and Waiver are used and word licence is not used section 30A and
inturn Section 19 (1) provision asking for written signature is less likely to come in to
picture and a public anouncement of relinqushment is supposed to be enough wide section 21
(But still we can not be 100 % sure since word licence is not defined in Indian Copyright
act)
4 C) CC0 Waiver seems to take care some more concerns arising out of section 19
subsection 2,3,4,5,6
4 D) Vis a vis to CC0 now refer to Section 21 subsection (3) and section 19 subsection
(8) It is perfectly ok that CC0 and Indian Copyright act are quite carefull enough that
those do not infringe upon non concenting other authors or rights of contractual oblgation
with a copyright society. But if in a given work's authorship or rights are shared by
non-concenting multiple authors or shared by a copy right society and and only one or
limited number of authors are conceting to CC0 declaration and by ommission or commission
are not disclosing existance of rights of other parties then there is (atleas an
hypothetical direct or indirect) lapse in fullfilling free cultural work definition that
expects
The work itself must not be covered by legal restrictions ....or limitations .... which
would impede the freedoms enumerated
As per my personal openion this possibility of lapse calls in(need) for some additional
measure or protocall to be followed in to confirm from CC0 concenting that there in no
such likely impediment from any other owner of the work or any copyright society. I
suppose Wikimedia commons also expects an upload should not have such impedement but
uploading user is not informed in clear terms of this requirement as of now. And that
needs and can be done through upload wizard.
Rgds.
Following is CC0 code. Code of other CC licences may be different and I have not studied
or refered to other CC licences for this discussion uptil now.
Creative Commons Legal Code
| |
| | | | | | | |
| Creative Commons Legal CodeOfficial translations of this legal tool are available in
other languages. ... |
| |
| View on
creativecommons.org | Preview by Yahoo |
| |
| |
Disclaimer
These are my personal perceptions and not a legal advice. For forma advice please always
consult to your own professional leagal adivisor . Legal disclaimers: 1,User:Mahitgar -
Meta , Wikipedia:Legal disclaimer - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia , उत्तरदायकत्वास
नकार (माहितगारकृत) | मिसळपाव
| |
| | | | | |
| Wikipedia:Legal disclaimer - Wikipedia, the free encyclopediaWikipedia contains articles
on many legal topics; however, no warranty whatsoever is made that any of the articles are
accurate. There is absolutely no assurance that any statement contained in an article
touching on legal matters is true, correct or precise. Law varies from place... |
| |
| View on
en.wikipedia.org | Preview by Yahoo |
| |
| |
| |
| | | | | |
| उत्तरदायकत्वास नकार (माहितगारकृत) | मिसळपावमिसळपाव या संकेतस्थळावर उपलब्ध माहितीनुसार
मिसळपाव संकेतस्थळ हे एक येथे नमुद धोरणांच्या परिघात सामुदायिक लेखन वाचन सहभागास अनुमती
देणारे खाजगी मालकीचे संकेतस्थळ आहे. सदर संकेतस्थळाने दिलेल्या नियमांच्या चौकटीच्या मर्यादा
सांभाळून संगणक वापरणार्या व आंतरजाल जोडणी उपलब्ध असलेल्या क... |
| |
| View on
www.misalpav.com | Preview by Yahoo |
| |
| |
| |
| | | | | |
| User:Mahitgar - Meta* Disclaimer wmf:Wikimedia:General disclaimer
en:w:Wikipedia:General_disclaimer mr:w:विकिपीडिया:सर्वसाधारण_उत्तरदायकत्वास_नकार
en:w:Wikipedia:Legal disclaimer en:w:Wikipedia:Risk disclaimer |
| |
| View on
meta.wikimedia.org | Preview by Yahoo |
| |
| |
On Saturday, 11 July 2015 2:44 PM, Shyamal Lakshminarayanan
<lshyamal(a)gmail.com> wrote:
Mahitgar,
Seeing the comments on the talk page I think the confusion is due to the lack of context
that seems to force the reader to think between the lines. For instance on my first read
it looked like you were implicitly stating that the requirement of 'free cultural
work' is not being met by the CC licensing variants available. Perhaps this deals only
with relinquishing copyright - ie releasing into the "public domain" rather than
licensing? My belief has been that CC0 works in the Indian jurisdiction. Assuming that you
are stating it does not, it might help to specifically explain why you think CC0 does not
work in India.
best wishes
[[en:User:Shyamal]]
On Sat, Jul 11, 2015 at 12:49 PM, Mahitgar from Marathi Wikipedia
<mahitgar(a)yahoo.co.in> wrote:
This is a Peer review request to seek broader input to improve page: meta:Help:Form I
& Affidavit (Customised for relinquishment of copyright as per 'free cultural
work' definition) an option available under (Indian) Copyright act 1957 rules.
Rgds
Mahitgar
_______________________________________________
Wikimediaindia-l mailing list
Wikimediaindia-l(a)lists.wikimedia.org
To unsubscribe from the list / change mailing preferences visit
https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikimediaindia-l