On Feb 24, 2007, at 9:40 PM, geni wrote:
Wikipedia:Notability (academics)]]
If we didn't have a notability guideline on porn stars, this would be
our worst one. It's ridiculously selective, and fails the sniff test
in the humanities. It should be a slam dunk that anybody who has
published in PMLA or Critical Inquiry should, at the very least, have
an article outlining that work. Absolute dead-on common sense, and if
this were true it would immediately boost the quality of articles in
this area astronomically. If I didn't suspect that it would get
ripped out by a mob of deletionists, I'd work my way through the last
decade of Critical Inquiry putting in summaries of the work published
in it. But I won't, because I'm not willing to invest that kind of
time in order to have someone tag it for deletion.
-Phil