On 15/08/2010, WereSpielChequers <werespielchequers(a)gmail.com> wrote:
Having a jury system instead of anyone who cares
enough about that
article or deletions in general would be a tad unwiki, and I suspect
only the extremists on both sides would willingly serve on such juries
in any number. Even then I doubt you would get large enough numbers to
replicate AFD.
It's not that you wouldn't hold an AFD, it's just that the decision
would be made by the jury rather than the admin, like in a trial.
People would still be able to roll up whenever they want and put their
opinion about the relative merits of an article.
The point is that the random choice of the jury allows for a straight
vote among the jury. Right now, there's odd stuff going on sometimes.
WereSpielChequers
--
-Ian Woollard