[Wikiquality-l] Implicit vs Explicit metadata
Platonides
platonides at gmail.com
Sun Dec 2 22:11:53 UTC 2007
Aaron Schulz wrote:
> Article Trust(cons)
> 1) Template and image vandalism is still a problem
> 2) Bot and AWB edits flying through pages automatically make the trust
> of large chunks of text increase
Bots shouldn't increase the trustiness of the articles they edit.
> Article Trust(cons):
> 1) Again, bots and such
> 2) You cannot edit anything without vouching for it (bad for fixing
> typos) and the text around it. Either people get afraid to edit or
> dubious text gets more and more "trusted"
> 3) No one necessarily committed to having fact-checked anything
Due to this maybe you could add a checkbox of "I'm not voting it" (also
useful for the AWB problem) but
a) It could lead to an abuse of it.
b) You can't apply article trust from outside.
More information about the Wikiquality-l
mailing list