[Wikipedia-l] The board has overstepped its mandate and authority (was: mail WikiSpecies)
Daniel Mayer
maveric149 at yahoo.com
Tue Sep 14 19:57:10 UTC 2004
--- Angela <beesley at gmail.com> wrote:
> The wiki is there to allow discussion to take place and to evolve what
> features are needed.
*That* is what Meta is for. Fork.
> This is most definitely not a fork of Wikipedia. Wikispecies is more
> about collecting data than writing articles. This data will be saved
> in a way that allows all Wikipedias, not just the English one, to use
> the data. As a project, Wikispecies has different aims to Wikipedia.
> It is aimed at the needs of scientific users rather than general
> users. Integrating Wikispecies into Wikimedia prevents a fork.
*That* is what the Commons is for. Fork.
> The board met at the start of this month, and the notes from this
> meeting are on Meta and the Foundation wiki. Four members voted to
> support the following points:
Creating this when there was significant (Id say large) amount of concerns and
opposition oversteps the bounds of the board, IMO. New projects *must* be
started when there is a consensus to do so, *not* by fiat. I cant believe this
is happening.
> I apologize to those who had not seen the above report already.
> Perhaps we need to find a way of ensuring that people who do not
> follow either of those wikis are aware of meetings that take place
> such as this one.
Perhaps we need to return to a consensus decision-making process instead of one
by fiat.
Truly disgusted,
Daniel Mayer (who is now seriously re-evaluating his participation in Wikipedia
and Wikimedia)
__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around
http://mail.yahoo.com
More information about the Wikipedia-l
mailing list